Skip to main content

Heat: Tips & Tricks

Heat: Tips & Tricks

Problem Solving Guide

Algorithm

 

General problems 

Since heat is a mechanism for transferring thermal energy between systems, expect some heat problems to really be problems about changes in $E_{th}$ according to the First Law. In the previous section you were typically given 2 of the variables out of $Q$, $W$, and $\Delta E$ and asked to calculate the other. In this section you will mostly be using the following two equations:

$Q_f = \pm mL_{f,v}$

or

$Q=mc\Delta T$

In general, you will be given a few variables and asked to solve for another - such as being given a mass, heat capacity, and change in temperature of an object, and asked how much thermal energy was transferred into our out of the object as heat. Or, you may be asked, for a given type of object, how much its temperature would change when in contact with a thermal reservoir that transfers some $Q_H$ amount of heat. For most of these problems, read the prompt carefully and take an inventory of your knowns and unknowns and the rest should be straightforward. Being able to do this comfortably will help enormously with calorimetry problems.

 

Calorimetry

Remember that calorimetry specifically refers to isolated systems with constant volume, so both the change in thermal energy of the system and work done on or by the system is zero ($ \Delta E = W = 0$). 

1. For all calorimetry problems, begin by summing the heat flow in into and out of the system:

$\Sigma Q = Q_1 + Q_2 + Q_3 + ... = 0$ 

 

2. After summing the sources of heat flow, read the problem statement again and verify that you haven't missed any sources (this is a common mistake students make - misreading a problem and missing that there is a phase change, for example). 

3. Re-write the sum in terms of definitions. For each $Q$, plug in its $mc\Delta T$. If phase changes are present and thus you have heats of transformation present, replace $Q$ with $mL_v$ or $mL_f$ with $v$ for vaporization, $f$ for fusion.

For example, pretend you put a hot rock in a container of liquid water and you observe steam. The equation to describe this is

$\Sigma Q = Q_{rock} + Q_{water,l} \pm Q_{v,water} + Q_{water,g}$ 

which is re-written as

$\Sigma Q = m_{r}c_{r}\Delta T_{r} + m_{w,l}c_{w,l} \Delta T_{w,l} + m_{v,w} L_{v, w} + m_{w,g}c_{w,g}\Delta T_{w,g}$

*The $\pm$ in front of the heat of vaporization term in the first equation was replaced by a $+$ sign in the second equation because we know the transformation was from liquid to vapor, and that is the sign convention for such a phase transition.

4. This equation should include all of the information you need to solve the problem. Note that since the systems are in thermal contact, they will come to thermal equilibrium and thus have the same final temperature $T_f$, but not the same $\Delta T$.

Often the point of a calorimetry problem is to find a final temperature, although sometimes the final temperature is given and you are asked for the heat exchange between particular sub-systems (such as the amount of thermal energy required to produce as much steam as was observed). Remember that the final temperature should be somewhere between the initial temperatures of the sub-systems (liquid water and hot rock); if it is somewhere outside, you probably made a calculation mistake or have a sign error somewhere (check that your $\Delta T = T_f - T_i$ have the correct signs).

Misconceptions & Mistakes

  • Heat is a mechanism by which thermal energy is transferred between systems. A system does not "contain" heat - it is not a state variable like P, V, T, N (and S).
  • Note that just because a phase change is taking place doesn't mean $W=0$; you can change liquid water to steam by changing the pressure of its container. 

Pro Tips

  • Practice practice practice. This section looks like a giant hair ball at first (especially calorimetry questions), but ends up being straightforward if you are careful and take your time. You will have lots of variables to keep track of (and lots of them are $Q_{something}$), so the more you practice keeping track of them, the easier your life will be. 

Multiple Representations

Multiple Representations is the concept that a physical phenomena can be expressed in different ways. 

Physical

Physical Representations describes the physical phenomena of the situation in a visual way.

Heat transfer occurs from the flame to the water in the cup. It takes energy through heat transfer to change the temperature of the water in the cup. As we add heat to the system the energy increases with respect to time.

This is a representation of a mug in a initial and final state. Initially, the mug has some water in the cup with a candle under it. A few hours later, the cup is steaming because of the heat transfer from the candle to the water inside of the cup.

Mathematical

Mathematical Representation uses equation(s) to describe and analyze the situation.

$Q = mc\Delta t$, where c is specific heat

$Q = \pm mL_{f,v}$, where L is latent heat

Calorimetry if all the transfer occurs in an isolated system, then we have the following:

$\Delta Q_{tot} = 0$ then $\sum Q = 0 \implies Q_1 + Q_2+Q_3 ... Q_n =0$


A representation with the words heat on the top. There is an equation that shows that the heat transferred to or from a system is equal to the product of the mass, specific heat, and change in temperature. This is also written in words below


A representation with the words specific heat on the top. There is an equation that shows that the specific heat is equal to one over mass multiplied by the change in energy divided by the change in temperature. This is also written in words below


A representation with the words heat of transformation fusion on the top. There is an equation that shows that the heat of transformation fusion is equal to plus or minus the mass multiplied by the latent heat of fusion, which is a material property. This is also written in words below


A representation with the words heat of vaporization fusion on the top. There is an equation that shows that the heat of transformation vaporization is equal to plus or minus the mass minus the mass multiplied by the latent heat of fusion, which is a material property. This is also written in words below

Graphical

Graphical Representation describes the situation through use of plots and graphs.

The graph describes the general phase transitions for a material. Notice the transition phases from solid to liquid and liquid to gas are constant temperature. Different materials have different temperature values where the phase transition occurs.

This is a graphical representation of general phase transitions for a material. The y axis is the temperature and the x axis is the energy or heat. Initially, the material starts as an solid with increasing energy will increase in temperature until it reaches a phase when it is being transformed into a liquid in which temperature temporarily plateaus. Then when all of the material is melted into a liquid, with increasing energy it also increases in temperature until the graph temporarily plateaus as all of the material is being transformed into a gas. Then as more energy is put into the system, temperature continuously increases.

 

Descriptive

Descriptive Representation describes the physical phenomena with words and annotations.

Referring to the Graphical Representation that describes the phase transitions of a material. During the initial solid phase the temperature increases and we add energy to the system until we reach the first phase change where we have reach the temperature required for the material to undergo the first phase transition. The next phase is the liquid to solid transition, where the material requires more added energy to the system to raise the temperature and complete the last phase transition.

Experimental

Experimental Representation examines a physical phenomena through observations and data measurement.

 We can begin with an ice cube, a closed lid cup, a thermometer, and a bunsen burner. We place the ice cube inside the cup and insert the thermometer and close the lid around the thermometers. Place the the cup over the bunsen burner and ignite the flame. Record the temperature and observe the state of the matter. We can then use this information to plot a phase change diagram as depicted in the Graphical representation and observe the temperature as it relates to the energy required for the ice to undergo transitions from ice to water to gas.

Arrow that takes you back to the Fundamentals section